International Bully Stud Service & Semen Shipping (2026)
International American Bully Breeding
International Bully Stud Service & Semen Shipping (2026)

International breedings don’t fail because of “bad semen.” They fail because breeders run global logistics with local habits. This guide gives you the systems: decision frameworks, timelines, paperwork strategy, and clinic execution that convert a shipped semen straw into a real litter — without gambling your cycle.
AI Summary
International Bully breeding works when three things align: timing, paperwork, and veterinary execution. For most international destinations, frozen semen shipped in a dry shipper is the safer option because customs delays and flight changes can ruin chilled timing. Your highest-probability plan is: select a proven stud, choose the shipping method that survives your route, start permits early, run progesterone testing, and use an experienced repro clinic (TCI or surgical often performs best for frozen).
Table of Contents
- People Also Ask (Featured Snippet Targets)
- What This Guide Covers (and What It Doesn’t)
- Why International Breedings Fail
- Decision Frameworks That Prevent Wasted Cycles
- How to Choose a Stud for International Production
- Chilled vs Frozen: The Global Reality
- Paperwork & Compliance: The Real Checklist
- The International Timeline: What to Do and When
- Progesterone Timing + AI/TCI/Surgical Strategy
- Shipping Logistics: Routing, Tracking, Dry Shippers
- Customs & Clearance: Avoiding Holds
- Region Notes (Canada / EU / UK / Asia / Middle East)
- Costs, Budgets, and Simple Calculators
- Common Buyer Mistakes (and Fixes)
- Step-by-Step Checklists (Copy/Paste)
- How to Book Venomline Internationally
- Voice Search Optimization
- Exactly 10 FAQs
- Helpful Links
- About the Author
- Legal & Veterinary Disclaimer
Venomline Stud Service — Booking, Fees & Proven Producers
This article is part of Venomline’s stud service education series. For current Pocket Bully studs, stud service options, and stud credits, use the official pages below. These links contain the most up-to-date availability, pricing, and booking steps.
Quick Booking Checklist (Best Results)
- ✅ Choose your producer first (pedigree + production proof)
- ✅ Confirm chilled vs frozen semen and your breeding method
- ✅ Use progesterone testing to time AI/TCI for highest conception odds
- ✅ Reserve early with a deposit or lock in paid-in-full stud credits
- ✅ Review contract terms, shipping windows, and vet requirements
Stud Service FAQs (Fast Answers)
Stud fees vary by producer, pedigree, and booking method. For current pricing and availability, use the studs hub.
Yes. Venomline offers nationwide semen shipping with timing guidance based on progesterone testing and your vet’s breeding method.
Deposits reserve your booking slot with a chosen producer. Paid-in-full stud credits lock in discounted pricing and priority scheduling.
Ready to book? Start at Available Studs & Fees, then follow the step-by-step process.
Can Bully semen be shipped internationally?

Yes. International canine semen shipments are possible when your destination’s import rules are met and your shipping method matches your timeline. Frozen semen is usually safer internationally because it survives delays and can be stored on arrival.
The real question isn’t “can it ship.” The real question is: can your plan survive delays, clearance, and clinic execution without missing the fertile window?
Is chilled or frozen better for international semen shipping?

For most international routes, frozen is better because it can be stored and used precisely when progesterone indicates the correct window. Chilled can work when transit is reliably fast and your clinic can inseminate immediately on delivery.
| Method | Best When | Weakness | Best Clinic Execution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chilled | Direct routing, predictable clearance, same-day insemination | Delays can end the cycle | Vaginal AI (or TCI if recommended) |
| Frozen | Long routes, strict countries, unpredictable customs, time zone complexity | Depends heavily on clinic skill | TCI or surgical AI with experienced repro vet |
How do you time breeding with shipped semen?
You don’t “guess days.” You run progesterone tests, track the trend, and schedule insemination based on your clinic’s protocol for chilled vs frozen semen. The shipping date is built backward from the insemination appointment — not the other way around.
What matters most for international breeding success?
Three variables drive results: (1) progesterone-based timing, (2) an experienced reproduction clinic (especially for frozen), and (3) paperwork started early enough to avoid clearance delays.
How early should I plan an international breeding?
Plan 4–8 weeks ahead whenever possible. That window gives you time to confirm your clinic, start permits, and choose the shipping method that matches your destination’s reality.
What paperwork is usually required to import dog semen?
Requirements vary by country, but commonly include an import permit, a veterinary health certificate, and shipment/label documentation that matches the destination’s rules.
What is a dry shipper for frozen semen?
A dry shipper is a nitrogen vapor container that keeps frozen semen at cryogenic temperatures during transport. It’s the standard for international frozen shipments because it protects viability over long timelines.
Which insemination method is best for frozen semen?
Frozen semen often performs best with TCI or surgical insemination performed by an experienced reproduction veterinarian. Your outcome is strongly tied to clinic skill, not marketing.
How do you avoid customs delays with semen shipments?
Start permits early, ensure names/IDs match across all documents, use a proven route with fewer handoffs, and default to frozen when delays are possible.
How do I book international stud service with Venomline?
Reserve service, confirm your receiving clinic and destination requirements, then align collection/shipping with progesterone timing. The fastest way is to start at the Venomline stud pages and the “How Stud Service Works” guide.
What this guide covers (and what it doesn’t)

This is the international breeding playbook for Bully programs — written for breeders who want repeatable outcomes, not lucky cycles. It covers chilled vs frozen decisions, the paperwork workflow, the timeline, clinic execution, shipping logistics, customs risk control, budgeting, and the step-by-step checklists you can actually follow.
What it does not do: it does not replace destination authority instructions, your veterinarian’s protocols, or legal advice. International requirements change. The purpose of this page is to make your plan bulletproof so when requirements change, you have a system that adapts without collapsing.
The Core Principle
International breeding is a chain. A chain fails at the weakest link. Your job is to remove weak links before heat starts: pick the right method, pick the right clinic, start paperwork early, and build your shipping timeline around progesterone timing — not around convenience.
Why international breedings fail (the real reasons)

Most “international failures” are not genetic failures. They are process failures. Breeders spend money on a stud and then run the rest of the pipeline like it’s local: they start paperwork late, choose chilled on a risky route, skip a true progesterone plan, or use a clinic that isn’t experienced with the method they selected.
Failure #1: Paperwork started during standing heat
Permits and certificates don’t care about your female’s timeline. If your destination needs an import permit or endorsements, starting late turns the border into a coin flip.
Fix: Start paperwork 4–8 weeks before expected heat whenever possible.
Failure #2: Chilled chosen on a route that can’t guarantee speed
Chilled can be excellent — but only when transit and clearance are predictable. International delays can erase the window before the clinic even opens the box.
Fix: If you can’t control delays, use a method that survives delays (frozen).
Failure #3: Progesterone guessed instead of measured
Calendar-day breeding is gambling. Progesterone trends are the steering wheel — they tell your clinic when to inseminate and tell you when to ship.
Fix: Test early, test consistently, and follow clinic protocol based on semen type.
Failure #4: Frozen shipped to a clinic that “does some AI”
Frozen success depends heavily on clinic execution. A clinic that rarely handles frozen (or does not specialize in repro) can reduce your odds even if the semen is perfect.
Fix: Use a true repro clinic and choose TCI/surgical when appropriate.
Reality: International breeding isn’t “local breeding + shipping.” It’s logistics + medicine + timing + compliance — executed under pressure.
Decision frameworks that stop wasted cycles

Most breeders don’t need more “info.” They need clear decisions. Use these frameworks to pick the correct method and reduce risk before you spend.
Framework 1: The Route Risk Score (choose chilled vs frozen in 60 seconds)
Score your route. If you score high, chilled becomes a gamble and frozen becomes the smart default.
| Risk Factor | 0 Points | 1 Point | 2 Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Connections | Direct / 1 handoff | 2 handoffs | 3+ handoffs |
| Customs predictability | Known fast clearance | Occasional holds | Frequent holds / strict paperwork |
| Arrival day/time | Weekday morning | Weekday afternoon | Weekend/holiday or after-hours |
| Clinic readiness | Immediate insemination | Same-day possible | Not guaranteed |
| Time zone complexity | Small difference | Moderate difference | Large difference / hard coordination |
Interpretation: 0–3 = chilled may be viable; 4–6 = chilled is risky; 7+ = frozen is the professional default.
Framework 2: The Probability-Per-Cycle Rule (how pros think)
International isn’t about “cheapest cycle.” It’s about highest probability per cycle. If you miss one cycle because you cut corners, you often spend more than you saved — and lose months of time.
Rule of thumb: If a decision increases your chance of success meaningfully (clinic quality, frozen for risky routes, early permits), it’s usually cheaper than repeating the entire cycle.
Framework 3: “Pick Clinic First” (the order that wins)
Breeders often choose a shipping method and then look for a clinic. That’s backwards. Frozen success depends on the clinic. If your clinic is elite with frozen, you can plan with confidence. If your clinic is not, you can be perfect on paperwork and still miss the cycle.
Correct order: Clinic ➝ method ➝ paperwork ➝ progesterone plan ➝ ship/collect schedule ➝ execution.
How to choose a stud for international production (not hype)

International breedings amplify cost, complexity, and risk. That means your stud choice must be based on predictability and production proof, not just a viral photo. Your goal is not “a cool litter.” Your goal is “a litter that builds a program and sells in your market.”
The 5 filters that select winners
- Production proof: consistent litters, not a one-off.
- Cross versatility: stamps across multiple female types.
- Fault awareness: improves what your female lacks (not doubling the same weaknesses).
- Market fit: produces puppies buyers in your country will pay for.
- Process support: clear contract, logistics help, realistic guidance.
The traps that destroy budgets
- Breeding for a color trend with no structure plan.
- Choosing a stud that only “works” in perfect conditions.
- Ignoring temperament stability because “he’s extreme.”
- Going international without a plan for puppy placement.
- Assuming the clinic can handle frozen because they say “we do AI.”
Venomline Proof Pages
If you’re building internationally, don’t buy claims — buy evidence. Use these pages to validate production and consistency:
Chilled vs frozen semen for international shipping (the honest breakdown)

Chilled and frozen aren’t “better vs worse.” They’re different tools with different risk profiles. The winning move is choosing the tool that matches your route, paperwork complexity, and clinic execution.
Chilled semen (international)
Chilled can work when your logistics are clean: fast transit, predictable clearance, and a clinic ready to inseminate immediately. The advantage is simplicity and strong performance when timing is correct.
- Best when: direct routes, predictable clearance, clinic can inseminate same-day.
- Pressure: high. Delays can end the cycle.
- Execution: clinic must treat arrival time like an appointment, not like “whenever.”
Frozen semen (international)
Frozen is the global workhorse because it survives delays and allows storage at the receiving clinic. The tradeoff is that your outcome depends heavily on clinic skill and method selection.
- Best when: long routes, strict paperwork, unpredictable customs, time zone complexity.
- Flexibility: high. Store and inseminate at the correct window.
- Execution: often strongest with TCI or surgical AI.
The simplest rule that saves money
If your route can be delayed and you can’t guarantee immediate insemination, chilled is a gamble. Frozen is the default because it turns “delay” from cycle-ending to manageable.
Learn more: Progesterone Testing in Dogs (2026 Guide): Breeding Timing & Results
Paperwork & compliance: the real checklist (not the fantasy)

Paperwork requirements differ by country, but the pattern is consistent: the destination wants permission to receive it, and the shipment must be certified and labeled correctly before export. The easiest way to lose time is to assume paperwork is a formality.
Common Requirements (Most Destinations)
- Import permit (destination authority; typically handled by the receiving party/clinic).
- Veterinary health certificate (format often destination-specific).
- Collection/ID documentation (stud identification details, labeling requirements).
- Container/shipping details (especially for dry shipper shipments).
- Advance notification (some ports require pre-alerting).
Requirements can change and may depend on ports of entry, clinic approvals, and destination authority updates. Verify through your receiving clinic and official guidance.
The most common paperwork failure is not “missing documents.” It’s mismatched information: names that don’t match, IDs that don’t match, dates that don’t align, or certificates written in a format the destination won’t accept. International compliance is about removing ambiguity.
Non-negotiable: Every name/ID on the certificate must match the shipment labels and the clinic’s paperwork. No “close enough.” Close enough becomes a hold.
The international timeline: what to do and when
International success is mostly decided before the female is even in standing heat. Below is a practical timeline that prevents last-minute chaos.
| When | What You Do | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| 6–8 weeks out | Choose stud, confirm clinic, decide chilled vs frozen, outline paperwork needs | Prevents “heat panic” and rushed decisions |
| 4–6 weeks out | Start import permit process, confirm health certificate format, confirm port/clearance plan | Paperwork delays are the #1 international killer |
| 2–3 weeks out | Confirm routing, tracking, clinic storage readiness, and insemination method | Reduces handoff risk and last-minute reschedules |
| Heat begins | Start progesterone testing schedule, set tentative insemination window | Removes guessing; locks timing |
| Window approaches | Lock collection and ship date around clinic appointment | Execution phase: timing becomes everything |
High-leverage move: Choose your receiving clinic first. A strong clinic makes frozen shipments predictable and reduces the risk of “everything was perfect but it still failed.”
Progesterone timing + AI/TCI/surgical strategy (how winners execute)

Progesterone testing is not a “nice-to-have.” It’s the mechanism that converts semen into puppies. Your veterinarian uses progesterone trends to estimate ovulation and schedule insemination based on semen type and method. Labs and clinics can vary in protocols, so the smart move is to choose a clinic with a clear plan and follow it consistently.
If you want the deeper timing blueprint
Use this supporting guide for a full progesterone-based approach to breeding days and method selection: Dog Progesterone Testing & Breeding Days (2026)
AI vs TCI vs Surgical: what changes internationally?
International breeding magnifies the cost of missing. That makes method selection practical, not emotional. Many clinics can perform standard vaginal AI. Fewer clinics are truly elite at TCI or surgical insemination. Frozen semen often rewards the clinics with real experience because timing windows can be narrower and precision matters.
Standard AI (vaginal insemination)
- Best for: chilled semen with clean timing and immediate execution
- Pros: widely available, less invasive
- Tradeoff: can be less forgiving when frozen is used
TCI (transcervical insemination)
- Best for: frozen semen with a skilled reproduction vet
- Pros: strong outcomes without surgery when performed correctly
- Tradeoff: skill-dependent; experience matters
Surgical insemination
- Best for: maximizing probability when frozen is used and clinic recommends it
- Pros: can deliver excellent outcomes in experienced hands
- Tradeoff: invasive; requires strict veterinary standards and informed consent
Always follow veterinary guidance. This guide provides operational strategy, not medical directives.
Breeder truth: Frozen is global currency. It pays out only when your clinic knows how to execute.
Shipping logistics: routing, tracking, dry shippers (what “professional” looks like)

International shipping is not just “send it and hope.” It’s route engineering. Your job is to minimize handoffs, control arrival timing, and ensure the receiving clinic is ready to accept and store the shipment without confusion.
Frozen shipments: the dry shipper playbook
Frozen semen is shipped in a dry shipper (nitrogen vapor container) to maintain cryogenic temperatures. The primary risks are not “temperature” as much as delays, handoffs, and clearance holds. Frozen minimizes those risks by allowing storage after arrival — but only if the receiving clinic can store immediately.
Frozen Shipping Checklist
- Route: prioritize fewer handoffs and predictable arrival windows.
- Docs: confirm certificate language matches labeling exactly.
- Tracking: assign a point person who watches every scan event.
- Receiving clinic: confirm storage readiness before shipment departs.
- Contingency: know who to call if clearance stalls (clinic contact + any broker contact if used).
Chilled shipments: the “arrival equals appointment” rule
Chilled semen can work internationally, but it demands precision and speed. The clinic must be ready to inseminate on arrival, and your route must be engineered to avoid weekend or after-hours arrivals. If chilled arrives when the clinic can’t act, the clock keeps running.
Chilled success rule: Don’t schedule chilled to arrive “sometime.” Schedule it to arrive when the clinic is open, staffed, and ready to inseminate immediately.
Customs & clearance: preventing holds (and surviving them)

Customs is where international timing gets destroyed. Your objective is simple: remove ambiguity. Clearance delays often come from mismatched documents, unclear labeling, permits not finalized, or arrival at times when clearance is slower.
Reduce delays
- Confirm import permit is approved before shipping.
- Ensure names/IDs match across all documents and labels.
- Choose a port/arrival window that supports clearance.
- Have a reachable contact during arrival + clearance window.
- Default to frozen when uncertainty is real.
Avoid these mistakes
- Changing paperwork last minute.
- Shipping before permit is finalized.
- Weekend/holiday arrival with no plan.
- Assuming “the courier will handle it.”
- Sending chilled into a destination known for random holds.
Risk control: Frozen turns clearance delays into “annoying.” Chilled turns clearance delays into “cycle-ending.” Choose accordingly.
Region notes (Canada, EU, UK, Asia, Middle East)
Rules vary by country and can change. These notes are operational guidance — the point is to help you choose strategy and avoid predictable mistakes.
Canada
Proximity can make chilled feasible for some routes — when routing and clearance are predictable. Frozen remains the best option when you want flexibility and scheduling control.
European Union (EU)
Documentation formatting and compliance details often matter. Frozen is commonly the safer default because you can store and inseminate precisely after arrival.
United Kingdom
Expect documentation to be detail-sensitive. Frozen is typically the best plan unless you have an unusually clean chilled route and a clinic ready to inseminate immediately.
Asia / Middle East
Demand can be high and timelines can be long. Frozen is usually preferred due to long transit, climate variables, and the reality of clearance complexity.
Costs, budgets & simple calculators (non-medical)
International cost is not just the stud fee. It’s the entire pipeline: reservation, clinic execution, shipping, permits, and sometimes translation or broker help. Budgeting correctly reduces panic decisions during heat.
International Budget Buckets
| Bucket | What’s Inside | What Drives the Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Stud service | Stud fee / credit / deposit structure | Stud demand, terms, inclusions |
| Clinic execution | Progesterone tests, AI/TCI/surgical, storage | Method selected + clinic expertise |
| Shipping | Courier, routing, handling, dry shipper (frozen) | Distance, handoffs, container requirements |
| Compliance | Import permit, health certificate, endorsements | Destination strictness, timing, document complexity |
| Contingency | Delays, reschedules, extra storage days | Route risk, clearance unpredictability |
Simple calculator: “Total Cycle Exposure”
Use this rule-of-thumb calculator to avoid underbudgeting. It’s not medical — it’s logistics math.
Total Cycle Exposure = Stud service + Clinic execution + Shipping + Compliance + (Contingency buffer)
Contingency buffer rule: If you’re using chilled internationally, buffer higher because delays can force re-shipping or a missed cycle. If you’re using frozen with clinic storage, buffer lower because delays are survivable.
Common buyer mistakes (and fixes)

If you want to outrun competitors, cover what they skip: mistakes, fixes, and operational detail. These are the failures that show up in real international breedings — and exactly how to prevent them.
Mistake: booking the stud before confirming the clinic
Breeders reserve a stud, then scramble to find a clinic that can do frozen, store it, or schedule the correct method.
Fix: Choose clinic first, verify frozen capability, then reserve.
Mistake: treating progesterone testing like optional
Without a progesterone plan, you can ship at the wrong time, inseminate too early/late, and lose the cycle even with perfect semen.
Fix: Start early, test consistently, follow a clinic protocol.
Mistake: chilled on a high-risk route
International delays are normal. Chilled doesn’t forgive normal.
Fix: Use the Route Risk Score; choose frozen when risk is real.
Mistake: paperwork “should be fine”
“Should be fine” becomes a hold when names or IDs mismatch, or a permit isn’t finalized.
Fix: Verify every field matches — labels, certificates, permits.
Step-by-step checklists

Use these as your execution checklist. If you follow them, you remove most failure points before they happen.
Checklist A: International readiness (before heat)
- Pick your receiving repro clinic and confirm they can store frozen semen if applicable.
- Confirm the clinic’s recommended method for your semen type (AI vs TCI vs surgical).
- Confirm destination requirements (permit, certificate format, port preferences).
- Choose chilled vs frozen using route risk and clinic readiness.
- Build a timeline backward from insemination appointment windows.
- Assign one point person for tracking and one for paperwork coordination.
Checklist B: Heat + timing execution
- Start progesterone testing early and follow clinic instructions on frequency.
- Set a tentative insemination appointment window with the clinic.
- Lock collection and ship date only when progesterone trend supports timing.
- Confirm clinic readiness to receive/act at the planned arrival time.
- Track the shipment actively; do not “wait for updates.”
Checklist C: Customs & arrival
- Confirm import permit approval before shipping (when required).
- Verify labels match documents exactly (names, IDs, dates).
- Plan arrival on a weekday, during clinic hours, when possible.
- Have contacts ready for clearance questions.
- For frozen: move directly into clinic storage on arrival.
- For chilled: inseminate as soon as clinic protocol requires (often immediately).
How to book Venomline international stud service (step-by-step)

International clients win when they lock a clean process early. Here’s the operational path that keeps the cycle controlled.
Step 1: Start with the studs (choose proven production)
Select the stud that matches your program goals (structure, head, bone, type, market demand). Don’t select based on hype alone — select based on consistent results.
Step 2: Confirm your clinic + method
This is where serious international breeders separate from gamblers. Confirm your clinic is a true repro clinic, can store frozen semen (if applicable), and can execute the chosen method.
Step 3: Reserve the service + lock the timeline
Reserve using the method that matches your planning style (credit vs deposit), then align paperwork and shipping around progesterone timing. International execution requires discipline: you’re building a controlled pipeline, not improvising.
Voice Search
Yes. You can ship dog semen internationally when the destination import requirements are met and your clinic is prepared to receive and inseminate correctly.
Is chilled or frozen semen better for international shipping?
Frozen is usually better internationally because it survives delays and can be stored until progesterone timing is correct.
What’s the best insemination method for frozen semen?
Frozen semen often performs best with TCI or surgical insemination performed by an experienced reproduction veterinarian.
How early should I plan an international breeding?
Plan 4 to 8 weeks ahead when possible so permits, routing, clinic scheduling, and progesterone timing can be coordinated without rushing.
Frequently Asked Questions (10)
1) Should I choose chilled or frozen semen for international shipping?
Frozen is usually safer internationally because it survives delays and can be stored for precise timing. Chilled can work when transit is reliably fast and your clinic can inseminate immediately on arrival.
2) How early should I start paperwork for an international semen import?
Start as soon as you have a projected heat window — ideally 4–8 weeks ahead — because permits and certificate formatting can take time and delays can end your cycle.
3) What documents are commonly required to ship dog semen internationally?
Requirements vary by country, but commonly include an import permit, a veterinary health certificate, and shipment/label documentation that matches the destination authority’s requirements.
4) What is a dry shipper?
A dry shipper is a nitrogen vapor container used to transport frozen semen while maintaining cryogenic temperatures during international transit.
5) What insemination method is best for frozen semen?
Frozen semen often performs best with TCI or surgical insemination performed by an experienced reproduction veterinarian. Clinic skill can heavily impact results.
6) How do I time shipped semen with progesterone testing?
Your clinic uses progesterone trends to identify the fertile window and schedule insemination. Shipping and collection are aligned backward from the insemination appointment rather than guessed by calendar days.
7) Why do international breedings fail most often?
The most common failures are late paperwork, chilled shipments delayed in transit, missing progesterone-based timing, and using a clinic that isn’t truly experienced with the chosen method.
8) Can frozen semen be stored after arrival?
Yes. Storage at a qualified clinic is one of frozen’s main advantages and allows you to inseminate precisely when timing is optimal.
9) How do I reduce customs delays with semen shipments?
Start permits early, ensure names/IDs match across documents and labels, plan arrivals during business hours when possible, and default to frozen when delays are likely.
10) How do I book international stud service with Venomline?
Start by reserving your service, confirm your clinic and destination requirements, then run progesterone testing so collection and shipping can be aligned precisely with the insemination window.
Helpful Links
These are the most relevant Venomline pages to support international stud service planning and proof-based breeding decisions:
About the Author – Venomline Elite Team

Venomline’s expert team leads this guide—headed by the acclaimed author of The Bully Bible, founder of BULLY KING Magazine and a top-tier breeder. With 10+ years in breeding, training, and advocacy, Venomline has produced 50+ ABKC Champions and 25+ Grand Champions.
As passionate breed advocates, rescue donors, and volunteers, Venomline offers field-tested insights and expert guidance to help you raise a confident, well-trained Bully.
Legal & Veterinary Disclaimer
This content is educational and operational. It is not veterinary advice and not legal advice. International semen import/export requirements vary by country and can change. Always confirm current requirements through your destination authority and your receiving reproduction clinic. Always follow your veterinarian’s protocols for progesterone testing and insemination method selection.
Last Updated: January 19, 2026
Comments
0 Comments